Menu

MorningChores

Search
  • Homestead
  • Gardening
    • How to Start a Garden
    • Planting Zone Map
    • First & Last Frost Dates
    • Planting Calendar
    • Garden Size Calculator
    • Plant Growing Guides
    • Fertilizer Calculator
    • C/N Compost Calculator
    • Gardening Basics
  • Animals
    • Chickens
    • Beekeeping
    • Goats
  • DIY
  • More
    • Frugal Living
    • Food & Drinks
    • Home Decor
    • Survival & Prepping
    • Handmade
  • Gardening
    • Planting Zone Map
    • Frost Dates
    • Planting Calendar
    • Plant Growing Guides
  • Homestead
  • Money
  • Home Ideas
  • DIY
  • Raising Chickens
  • Food & Drinks
  • Products
  • Become a Writer at Morning Chores
  • About Us

How to Make Yummy Sour Cream in 24 Hours

By Jennifer Poindexter
Jennifer Poindexter

Jennifer is a full-time homesteader who started her journey in the foothills of North Carolina in 2010. Currently, she spends her days gardening, caring for her orchard and vineyard, raising chickens, ducks, goats, and bees. Jennifer is an avid canner who provides almost all food for her family needs. She enjoys working on DIY remodeling projects to bring beauty to her homestead in her spare times.

Print

If you buy an item via links on this page, we may earn a commission. Our editorial content is not influenced by commissions. Read the full disclosure.

Do you enjoy making food ingredients yourself?

It can save you money, help you to be more knowledgeable about what you’re consuming, and it tastes better too.

In my case, I enjoy making my own food because it makes me feel better. Therefore, anytime I find I can make something almost as easy as buying it, I’m on board.

If you enjoy sour cream on baked potatoes, to turn into a dip for your chips, or on top of your chili, you’ll be glad to know it’s extremely easy to make.

Here’s all you need to know to make your own DIY sour cream in a flash:

You’ll need:

  • 1 cup of heavy whipping cream
  • ¼ cup of buttermilk
  • Mason jar

1. Prep Your Jar

Since you won’t be canning sour cream, there’s no way to sanitize the jar during the process. Therefore, you must take care of your jar before you get started.

You can use a pint jar. However, if you need more sour cream, use a larger jar. If you use the portion listed above, you’ll have 1 ¼ cup of sour cream.

Once you find the right size mason jar to use, wash it thoroughly in warm soap and water. Be sure you rinse the jar well to make sure you don’t end up with soapy tasting sour cream.

After the jar has been washed, rinsed, and dried thoroughly be sure to sanitize it too. You do this by placing warm water inside the jar itself.

Place the jar in a pot of warm water and fill the pot with water until the jar is covered. Bring the water to a boil and allow the jar to remain in the boiling water for 10 minutes.

After the 10 minutes is up, use jar grabbers to safely remove the jar, and give it a few minutes to cool off to where you can safely handle it.

When your jar is clean and sanitized, you’re ready to begin the process of making a delicious homemade sour cream.

2. Mix the Ingredients

whipped sour cream

Pour one cup of whipping cream into the jar. Place ¼ cup of buttermilk into the jar too. Place a clean canning lid and ring on the jar.

You’re going to be shaking the ingredients, so it’s important to make sure the lid and ring are secured to avoid a mess.

When everything is tight, begin to shake the ingredients inside the jar. Shake with some oomph because you want to make sure the ingredients are mixed well.

3. Let Fermentation Do Its Thing

Sour cream is formed through fermentation. Fermented foods are excellent for you and your gut. Because 70% of our immune system is in our gut, we should focus on eating foods which will give us good bacteria.

With fermentation, it’s important for us to understand what a great thing it is to make our own sour cream, watch the process, and understand how well we’re feeding our bodies when we’re eating this product.

Once all the ingredients have been thoroughly mixed, allow the jar to rest at room temperature for approximately 24 hours.

Obviously, when making your own sour cream, you must make it ahead of time. If you’re in a pinch and need sour cream quickly, consider using plain yogurt in its place.

If you get into the habit of making sour cream regularly, you should have it when it’s needed. Over the 24-hour period, the lactic acid within the buttermilk will begin fermenting the whipping cream.

Many good things happen in this process, and by the end, you’ll have delicious sour cream.

4. Enjoy and Store

After the 24 hours is up, open the jar and give the ingredients a quick stir. If you’ve ever opened store-bought sour cream and found liquid at the top, you know this is normal.

Therefore, stirring will bring everything back together and give the sour cream the desired thicker consistency.

When the sour cream is complete, you can either use right away or store it in the fridge until you’re ready to use it.

As with store-bought sour cream, it should last for a few weeks. When it no longer holds its thick consistency, has an odd odor, or if you see anything growing on the sour cream or jar, you’ll know it’s time to toss and make a new batch.

I’m sure though you’ll enjoy it using to the point where it won’t have time to go bad before you consume it.

5. A Quick Note on Sour Cream

There are different types of buttermilk and other kinds of milk you can use to make sour cream. If you want a lower fat option, you may choose to go with half and half, whole milk, or even a lower fat milk.

You may also choose to make your own buttermilk instead of using store-bought cultured buttermilk. If you decide to use these other options, be advised your sour cream may not be as thick as what you’re accustomed to.

Don’t be alarmed if it ends up being a little runnier instead of the thick dollops you’re used to using. Like with most things, when you begin trying to lower the fat intake, the calories, or any other ingredients in the traditional recipes, it tends to alter the texture or consistency of the product.

As you can tell, making your own sour cream is an easy process. It requires a little forethought because of the 24-hour fermentation process.

Beyond the time frame, it should be a cost-effective and self-sufficient option to provide a condiment you and your family will love.

7 Quick Halloween Recipes to Make Hauntingly Mouthwatering Snacks

8 Delicious Recipes for Wildcrafted Fir or Spruce Tips

3 Proven Methods to Dehydrating Apples Every Gardener Should Know

24 Time-Saving Meals in a Jar Recipes for Breakfast, Lunch, and Supper

22 Delicious and Healthy Oatmeal Recipes That Are Not Bland at All

11 Succulent Venison Tenderloin Recipes That Are Restaurant Worthy

5 Root Cellar Alternatives to Save Your Harvest

How to Prepare and Preserve Nuts to Keep Them Fresh

4 Easy Methods to Make Healthy Dandelion Tea and 13 Recipes to Try Out

How to Make Mouthwatering Homemade Corn Relish in 6 Simple Steps

How to Can Food

Canning 101: The Complete Guide to Canning Food for Beginners

15 Delicious & Healthy Asian Vegetables You Must Know About

22 Sweet & Simple Rhubarb Dessert Recipes for a Delicious Treat

The 6 Simple Steps to Making Homemade Delicious Salsa Verde

13 Easy Steps on How to Butcher a Deer and Get the Perfect Venison

30 Delicious Blackberry Recipes You Should Try at Least Once

24 Interesting Ways to Use and Preserve Your Plums

How to Cure Garlic and Onions to Make Them Last

How to Make a Basic Chicken Stock and Store It for Later

33 Delicious Apple Cider Recipes to Get into the Mood for Fall

Dehydrate Food 101: All You Need to Know to Begin Dehydrating Food

21 Surprisingly Tasty Dandelion Recipes Straight From Your Back Garden

  • About Morning Chores
  • Jobs
    • Become a Writer
    • Short-Form Video Creator
  • Contact Us

© 2026 MorningChores. All rights reserved | Privacy Policy · Terms of Use · Disclosure