If you love to bake cookies for your kids or as a tasty treat for yourself, a cookie sheet is a must-have piece of bakeware for your kitchen. As well as being able to use a cookie sheet to bake your own delicious cookies, a cookie sheet is a perfect choice for baking all sorts of food. Food such as chocolate brownies, pizza, and also baked veggies or roast lamb.
The 6 Best Cookie Sheets
- USA Pan Bakeware Cookie Sheet
- Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Commercial Baker’s Half Sheet (Our Top Pick)
- Farberware Insulated Bakeware Nonstick Cookie Baking Sheet
- NutriChef Kitchen Oven Pans
- Rachael Ray 56524 Nonstick Bakeware Set
- T-Fal AirBake Natural 2 Pack Cookie Sheet Set
Our Top Pick for the Best Cookie Sheet
Our top pick for the best cookie sheet is the Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Commercial Baker’s Half Sheet.
This sturdy and also strong cookie half sheet has a high popularity rate among professional baking lovers. This is due to its commercial-style aluminum construction that can resist high temperatures without any warping or bending. It’s excellent non-stick properties and also a superior level of heat conductivity guarantee top quality baking results. And also fantastic delicious-tasting cookies every time.
Check the price on AmazonWhat Is a Cookie Sheet?
A cookie sheet is a flat rectangular baking pan or tray. Its flat design ensures that the heat is evenly distributed around and over your cookies so that they are baked properly without being overcooked or burnt. A cookie sheet may have a raised ½-inch rim on all sides of the sheet. This means you can use it to bake other types of food that need the raised rim to stop the juices or oil from leaking over the edges.
Or the cookie sheet might have a raised rim on just one side. This makes it easier to grasp and also lift the sheet in and out of the oven.
How to Choose the Best Cookie Sheet
When it comes to choosing a cookie sheet, you need to consider what the sheet is made out of. Also, its capacity to hold small or large amounts of cookies. You also have to consider the cookie sheet’s non-stick and anti-warping and also anti-rusting properties.
As most cookie sheets are made out of a material that is thinner than a normal baking pan, the material is of the utmost importance as a cookie sheet can warp in the oven in high temperatures or the non-stick coating may peel off. This means the sheet will only last a short time.
The best types of materials for a cookie sheet is aluminum. It can be pure 100% aluminum or aluminized steel. Some heavy-duty cookie sheets are made out of carbon steel.
Aluminum
Aluminum is a great choice for a cookie sheet for a few reasons. It is strong and also durable. It has natural non-stick properties.
Some cookie sheets that are made out of natural, pure 100% aluminum, such as the Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Commercial Baker’s Half Sheet or the T-Fal AirBake Natural 2 Pack Cookie Sheet Set have very good anti-warping and rust-resistant properties. They also have a superior level of heat conductivity, which is just right for baking cookies.
One thing to remember about aluminum cookie sheets is that they are usually thinner than solid carbon steel. They may only have a single-ply construction. Meaning they may bend in high temperatures.
Some cookie sheet manufacturers that use aluminum use a new type of baking technology during the manufacturing process. T-Fal (Tefal) uses “micro-dome” technology in its AirBake cookie sheet. This innovative technology is designed to shorten your baking time up to 15%.
As the sheet has two heavy-duty aluminum sheets that encase a thin layer of air, this also helps the heat to distribute evenly. It also prevents any overcooking or burning.
Aluminized Steel
Like pure aluminum, aluminized steel is a favorite with many commercial bakers. Some manufacturers such as USA Pan, prefer this material. It has a high level of durability. It also delivers an excellent baking performance.
Heavy-Duty Carbon Steel
Heavy-duty carbon steel is super strong so your cookie sheet will pretty much last a lifetime. The high strength that is synonymous with carbon steel results in an even and consistent heat distribution throughout the cooking process. This means that your cookies will be deliciously moist and baked to perfection.
Carbon steel cookie sheets also have ultra anti warping and rust-resistant properties so they can resist higher oven temperatures.
The Rachael Ray 56524 Nonstick Bakeware Set is an excellent choice. Not only for baking cookies but all sorts of food. This cookie sheet is also designed to resist any warping and minimize any hot spots, which gives you a superior level of baking.
Some cookie sheets such as the Farberware Insulated Bakeware Nonstick Cookie Baking Sheet not only includes the strength of carbon steel but it has special insulating properties, similar to the T-Fal AirBake Natural 2 Pack Cookie Sheet Set. Its unique two-level pan surface encloses an air pocket that allows the heat to circulate around your cookies so that you can enjoy consistent baking results.
One of the best things about carbon steel cookie sheets is that the material is usually a little bit thicker than aluminum. So it is strong enough to hold a lot of heavier food items, such as roast vegetables, a lamb roast, or French fries.
Non-Stick Abilities
While aluminum has a natural built-in non-stick ability, carbon steel also delivers a very good non-stick performance. Some manufacturers such as USA Pan have gone a step further. They design their cookie sheets with a unique fluted corrugated surface that is engineered to enhance its natural non-stick properties.
USA Pan also uses a special AMERICOAT® Plus coating on the sheet’s surface. This makes it so easy to remove your cookies. Farberware uses a light gray aluminum in its cookie sheet. Also, its satin surface allows your cookies to easily slide off onto a cooling rack or plate.
The downside of using carbon steel is that the surface can get scratched if you use metal utensils. It is also recommended that you do not put the cookie sheet into the dishwasher. So you have to wash it by hand.
Size
Cookie sheets come in a range of sizes, depending on the manufacturer. There are cookie sheets that are ideal for a few cookies and you can also fit a few of the smaller sized trays in the oven. If you want to bake cookies for a party or you just want to have a lot of cookies on-demand for a brood of hungry kids, then a larger cookie sheet is the best choice.
Sizes can range from a quarter sheet pan (13.5 x 9-inches), a medium sheet pan (15 x 11.5-inches). Or a jumbo size sheet, (15 x 20-inches), which can hold up to two dozen cookies.
Taking Care of Your Cookie Sheet
Although some cookie sheets can be put into the dishwasher, the best way to maintain your cookie sheet is to hand wash it. Most cookie sheets in this buying guide and associated reviews have excellent non-stick surfaces. This allows you to easily remove the cookies after they have been baked. So washing them is very easy with warm, soapy water.
Also, depending on the material, whether it is pure aluminum, aluminized steel, or carbon steel, the cookie sheet may not be suited for very high temperatures. Always check the manufacturer’s specifications. This way your cookie sheet’s non-stick surface and overall appearance will maintain its original quality. And will continue to deliver a top-notch baking performance.
6 Best Cookie Sheets – Reviews
1. USA Pan Bakeware Cookie Sheet
USA Pan is a family-owned company that has been producing professional grade baked goods for over 50 years. Their bakeware is perfectly designed for the home cooking lover. As the USA Pan Bakeware Cookie Sheet is made according to high bakeware standards, you can be assured of top-quality cooking performance.
Whether it is chocolate chip cookies or cookies that are decorated with brightly colored smarties, the USA Pan large cookie sheet makes it so easy to bake delicious homemade cookies. They brown evenly, release quickly, and also come out tasting great! The cookie sheet is made from aluminized steel. Its thinner metal construction is designed to allow heat to distribute evenly.
The sheet’s unique fluted corrugated surface is engineered to enhance the steel’s natural non-stick properties. It also adds strength to the pan for extra warp resistance and facilitates proper air circulation. As the surface is specially treated with the AMERICOAT® Plus coating, non-stick silicone that is PTFE, PFOA, and also BPA free, your baked goods can be removed easily. You also do not need to use oil or parchment or baking paper!
With a secure, easy gripping handle and a tapered edge, the sheet allows you to grasp the sheet and lift it out of the oven and to slide your cookies straight onto a serving plate. The sheet is oven safe to 450°F. In order to maximize its service life, hand-wash with warm soapy water. To maintain the non-stick surface, use only nylon, silicone-coated, or wooden utensils.
The cookie sheet comes with a limited lifetime warranty cover.
USA Pan also makes other sizes in their cookie sheet range. However, make sure that you double-check the size you are ordering as the measurements represent the baking surface, not the overall pan size.
Pros
- Great quality
- Excellent value for money
- US made
- Large size
- Strong and also durable aluminized steel
- High even heat performance
- Anti-warping resistance
- Good weight
- Specially treated with the AMERICOAT® Plus non-stick coating
- Secure, easy-gripping handle
- Oven safe to 450°F
- Limited lifetime warranty
Cons
- Cannot use metal utensils
- Not dishwasher-safe
- Not ideal for very high temperatures
- Too big for a very small oven
2. Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Commercial Baker’s Half Sheet
The Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Commercial Baker’s Half Sheet was designed for commercial use. So it can withstand heavy-duty use and hot oven temperatures. With a strong natural, pure aluminum construction and reinforced encapsulated steel-rimmed edges, the half sheet can resist warping and rust for a lifetime of durability.
Its sturdy aluminum construction helps to provide a superior level of heat conductivity throughout the entire cookie sheet. This ensures that your food rises properly and is evenly baked. The sheet’s lighter color means your food will be browned consistently without any overcooking or burning.
The Nordic Ware half sheet measures 17.88 x 12.88 x 1.06-inches in size. The inside of the pan is 16.5 x 11.38 x 1-inch in size. This gives you the perfect amount of space for all sorts of baked goods from a dozen cookies, chocolate brownies, mini pizzas, or small baked vegetables like carrots, baby beetroot, onions, and also garlic. Nordic Ware also makes other sizes, like a big sheet and a quarter sheet to suit all sorts of baking applications.
Although it is designed for heavy-duty use, the cookie sheet is still quite lightweight at 2 pounds so you can carry it around easily. It will fit comfortably in most ovens and it is oven-safe up to 450°F.
You do not have to worry about any spills or your food falling off the sheet as the encapsulated steel raised all-around rim is oversized. You can easily grasp the cookie sheet when putting it in or taking it out of the oven. Even though the aluminum is un-coated, the aluminum construction has excellent non-stick properties. Making cleaning effortless.
Nordic Ware offers a limited lifetime warranty on all of its products. So if you experience any problems contact them and they will be happy to honor the warranty.
In order to maintain its high-quality construction, the Nordic Ware cookie sheet should not be put into the dishwasher. However, you can easily clean it with warm soapy water. Do not use metal utensils on the non-stick surface or scouring pads, steel wool, abrasive cleaners, or bleach as this destroys the sheet’s surface and will void any warranty.
Pros
- Top-quality cookie sheet
- Very affordable price
- Heavy-duty pure aluminum
- Sturdy construction
- Lightweight
- Large size can hold 12 cookies
- Versatile: can accommodate all sorts of food
- Oversized steel rims
- Easy to hold and also carry
- Superior heat conductivity
- Light aluminum color prevents any burning
- High anti-warping resistance
- Excellent non-stick properties
- Oven safe to 450°F
Cons
- Aluminum is not very thick
- Not recommended for small ovens
3. Farberware Insulated Bakeware Nonstick Cookie Baking Sheet
Farberware has been making bakeware for over 100 years. Its strong and durable sleek-looking Insulated Bakeware Nonstick Cookie Baking Sheet is an example of its high-quality products that deliver beautiful cooking results.
Whatever is on-demand in your household, butterscotch cookies, or fudge brownies, the jumbo cookie sheet measures 15.5 x 20-inches. So there is plenty of room for two dozen cookies or anything else that takes your fancy.
The extra-large cookie sheet has been made out of durable, heavy-gauge carbon steel construction that resists any warping, even after constant baking sessions. Its distinctive light gray two-level pan surface encloses an air pocket that creates an insulated, heated airflow. This is necessary for consistent baking results.
You do not have to worry about your cookies sticking to the baking sheet as it has a top-quality satin non-stick surface. One end of the pan is rimless to allow baked goods to easily slide to a cooling rack or serving plate. The other side has a slightly higher raised edge so that you can easily grip the sheet while carrying it from the oven to the countertop.
The Farberware cookie sheet is oven safe to 450°F. It comes with a limited lifetime warranty cover.
Although the cookie sheet should normally not warp, the sheet may flex as the metal expands in the high oven temperatures.
To keep the cookie sheet in tip-top condition, hand wash it in warm soapy water. Farberware guarantees quality assurance on their cookie sheet. However, if on the slight chance it arrives with a dent due to transport issues, they offer a limited lifetime warranty. So do not hesitate to call them for a replacement.
Pros
- Very good quality
- Jumbo size can accommodate two dozen cookies
- Excellent non-stick light gray satin surface
- Heavy-duty carbon steel
- Innovative design: double pan layers enclose an air pocket
- Top-quality baking results
- Very good anti-warping resistance
- Oven-safe to 450°F
- Easy to grip and also carry
- Rimless edge allows for easy food release
- Easy to clean
- Quality Assurance Guarantee
- Limited lifetime warranty
Cons
- Not dishwasher safe
- Satin surface can be slippery
- Sheet can arrive dented due to transport
4. NutriChef Kitchen Oven Pans
If you have a lot of baking to do, the NutriChef Kitchen Oven Pans offer you a lot of baking choices from traditional cookies to flavorful lamb racks or roast vegetables. The cookware set features three different cookie pan sizes: one small sheet pan (13.38 x 8.66-inches), one medium sheet pan (15.1 x 10.03-inches). And one large cookie pan (17.1 x 11.8-inches), so all of your baking needs are fulfilled.
You can expect a high-quality cooking performance from these cookie sheets. They are made out of durable food-grade carbon steel and can sustain heavy-duty baking. The attractive toxic-free, eco-friendly black surface has a good thickness. The red silicone easy grip and heat safe handles look great too. They will also add a splash of color to brighten up your kitchen.
As well as a stylish exterior, the carbon steel surface has a very good non-stick/stain-resistant ability. It also helps to evenly distribute the heating to minimize overcooking or hot spots. This in turn guarantees superb baking results. If you want to cook a roast, the cookie sheets have a depth of 0.59-inches and 0.67-inches, depending on the size, which will catch any juices.
For even more all-round baking, NutriChef makes an 8-Piece set and a 10-Piece set.
The cookie sheets are oven safe up to 446°F. Their stackable design will help you to save on storage space in a kitchen drawer.
Pros
- High quality
- Great value for money
- Three different sizes
- Made from durable carbon steel
- Very good non-stick and non-staining ability
- High baking performance
- Attractive non-toxic and also eco-friendly black surface
- Bright red silicone easy grip and heat safe handles
- Very good depth for roasting
- Oven safe up to 446°F
- Stackable design
Cons
- Handles can still get hot
- Pans can rust if you don’t dry them properly
- Cannot use metal utensils
- Not dishwasher-safe
5. Rachael Ray 56524 Nonstick Bakeware Set
The Rachael Ray 56524 Nonstick Bakeware Set is a stand-out feature in the Rachael Ray bakeware collection. These stunning cookie sheets will not disappoint you. The versatile cookie pans are the perfect choice for rustling up a quick batch of cookies for your hungry kids as well as baking up other types of sweet or savory treats.
The set includes three different sizes, 9 x 13-inches, 10 x 15-inches, and 11 x 17-inch. So there are plenty of options for all sorts of baking ideas.
The Cookie Pan Set is made from premium quality durable carbon steel that resists warping. Also, the cookie pans have a long-lasting non-stick surface to ensure that the cookie dough does not stick to the pan or burn. It also provides for a quick and easy clean-up.
The ergonomic wide silicone handles are comfortable to hold and also protects your hands from high heat. As well as featuring a super stylish dark gray color, the handles have Rachael Ray’s signature bright orange color which adds a special splash of color to your kitchen. The cookie sheets are oven safe up to 450°F.
Rachael Ray supports the non-profit organization, Yum-o!. It helps kids and their parents develop healthy relationships. A portion of the proceeds from this purchase goes to Yum-o!. The cookie bakeware set also comes with a quality assurance guarantee cover. So if you experience any problems, do not hesitate to contact the friendly customer service team.
Pros
- Great value for money
- Very good quality
- Solid and durable carbon steel
- Good anti-warping resistance
- Versatile three-piece pack
- Attractive dark gray surface
- Excellent non-stick ability
- Oven safe up to 450°F
- Bright orange ergonomic wide silicone handles
- Easy to hold and also carry
- Quality assurance guarantee
- Very good customer service
Cons
- Metal can bend in high temperatures
- Not dishwasher safe
- Can rust if the sheets don’t dry properly
6. T-Fal AirBake Natural 2 Pack Cookie Sheet Set
T-Fal is the proud owner of “The Original Insulated Bakeware”. Its absolute AirBake Natural 2 Pack Cookie Sheet Set construction guarantees fantastic cookies that are baked to perfection. As there are two 16 x 14-inches medium-sized cookie sheets in this set and they come at a very affordable price, why not purchase another pack as your cookies will soon be in high demand.
The cookie sheets are made from 100% aluminum which is strong and durable and also highly rust-resistant. They have a good warp resistance, so they can withstand heavy-duty baking. The secret to the cookie sheet’s baking success is due to its unique insulation technology called “micro-dome”.
This “micro-dome” technology will save you time in the kitchen. It will shorten your baking time up to 15% as the sheets have two heavy-duty aluminum sheets that encapsulate a thin layer of air. This prevents the top sheet from overheating. It also provides even heating distribution so that your cookies do not overcook or burn. The result is golden brown moist cookies that have just the right size, texture, and taste!
As well as top quality baking results, the aluminum material has very good non-stick properties. As the sheet has a 1-inch raised lip on one side, it is easy to grip the sheet and load or remove the sheet from the oven.
The AirBake cookie sheets are dishwasher safe. However, T-fal does not recommend using dishwasher detergent tablets as their high concentration will damage the bakeware’s special finish. In order to maintain your cookie sheets so that they continue to provide a high-quality baking performance, T-fal advises that you avoid overheating your bakeware. To stop the sheets from getting scratches, only use plastic utensils.
If the cookie sheets develop slight surface marks or abrasions, the marks or abrasions will not affect the performance of the non-stick coating. With continual use, the non-stick surface may become slightly darker. However, this will not impair its performance.
The cookie sheet two-pack also comes with a recipe book for more cookie baking ideas.
T-Fal stands behind its cookie sheets. Their confidence in their product is backed by their amazing 10-year warranty. They also have a solid reputation for honoring the warranty without any hassles. So do not hesitate to contact them if anything goes wrong with the cookie sheets within the warranty period. The AirBake cookie sheets are available in a smaller 14 x 12-inches sheet and also a larger 15.5 x 20-inches sheet.
Pros
- Great quality
- Excellent price
- Handy two-pack
- Unique insulation“micro-dome” technology
- 100% aluminum
- Easy to grip 1-inch raised rim
- Good medium-sized sheet
- Available in a smaller and also larger size
- Very good anti-warping and also rust resistance
- Bakes delicious cookies
- Easy to clean
Cons
- Not ideal for high oven temperatures
- Sheet can discolor over time
- Can bend in high temperatures
- Not recommended for use with metal utensils
- Not ideal for cleaning in the dishwasher
Our Top Pick for the Best Cookie Sheet
Our top pick for the best cookie sheet is the Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Commercial Baker’s Half Sheet.
This sturdy and also strong cookie half sheet has a high popularity rate among professional baking lovers. This is due to its commercial-style aluminum construction that can resist high temperatures without any warping or bending. It’s excellent non-stick properties and also a superior level of heat conductivity guarantee top quality baking results. And also fantastic delicious-tasting cookies every time.
Check the price on Amazon
